There are just some things you have to do when you go to a certain place. You have to visit the Pyramids when you go to Egypt. You have to visit the Eiffel Tower in Paris. You absolutely have to see the Sydney Opera House in Sydney. And you have to eat at Blue Heaven in Key West! But there are a few things to know in advance that might help you fit this into your plans for Key West, so I decided to pull together a blog post for you with all the things you need to know!
Expect a Wait
Blue Heaven is on a first-come, first-served basis for breakfast and lunch (from 8:00am-2:30pm), so don’t come hangry, and just plan to have a bit of a wait! When you put in your name, the hostess will estimate how long your wait will be, then take your phone number. You’ll immediately get a text welcoming you to Blue Heaven and asking you to wait, and you’ll get a second text when your table is ready.
More here: What to Know Before You Visit Key West
For reference, on a Tuesday in January (during the Pandemic), we got there around 11:15am and waited 20 minutes. On a Thursday in June, we got there around 12:45pm and waited about 45 minutes. I went by on a Saturday morning around 9:30, and the wait just to put your name on the waiting list was already down the block. It’s worth your time, but just be prepared to wait!
Nearby attraction: Everything to Know About Visiting the Truman Little White House
For dinner from (5:00pm-10:00pm), they take limited reservations. You can only make a reservation by phone from 10:00am-5:00pm Monday-Friday, or 10:00am-3:00pm Saturday. The number is 305-296-8666. I recommend booking six to eight weeks out to make sure you get a coveted dinner reservation!
More here: The Best Places to Eat in Key West
While You’re Waiting
Don’t want to waste your vacation time waiting? Then don’t! There are several things to do while you wait.
Right across the street, you’ll find Blue Heaven’s bar and waiting area, Andy’s Cabana. You can get a beverage, or if you accidentally did come hangry, you can also get a slice of their incredible banana bread! I got an iced coffee for myself (shocker), a couple of orange juices, and a cranberry juice for my parents and husband. This particular bar is cash only, but don’t worry, Blue Heaven does take a credit card.
Related: The Best Coffee Shops in Key West
The Gift Shop
While you’re waiting, take a look in their gift shop. They sell local art, locally made soaps and bath products, tee-shirts, and more! You can even get one of their key lime pies, a loaf of banana bread, fresh-baked bread, or their homemade granola to-go!
A little something to think about when you shop: The Business of Traveling for Good
You know I’m a huge advocate for supporting local shops and businesses! There are a few right across the street that sell clothing, jewelry, bags, and more, so take a look while you’re waiting. Don’t worry about missing Blue Heaven calling your name when your table’s ready–remember, you’ll get a text instead!
More here: Why It’s Okay to Be a Tourist
The restaurant itself is all open-air, and there will definitely be chickens and cats running around! You’ll most likely have live music with your meal, but we didn’t find it too loud or disruptive to conversation. It’s very casual, at least for breakfast and lunch, and I imagine it would be for dinner as well! We came for lunch right after spending the morning at Fort Zachary Taylor State Park, so we were ultra-casual.
Once you get your text and get yourself seated at the table, the real fun begins! Blue Heaven serves breakfast from 8:00am-2:30pm, and lunch starts at noon. Take a look at their menu online in advance if you like. Their story is also on the back of their menu, so you’ll also be able to do some light reading while you’re there!
Key West Shrimp Benedict
Key West shrimp are pink, slightly sweet, and mild in flavor. They go well with Benedict! Other Benedict options include veggie, bacon, ham, sausage, beef tenderloin, or lobster BLT!
More here: The Most Exotic Foods in the World
Blue Heaven Omelette
The Blue Heaven Omelette comes with Vermont white cheddar, and you’ll have your selection of add-ons. I added spinach and bacon to mine, and asked for a side of fresh banana bread instead of toast!
Check out my World Foods Page for more!
Rooster Special Breakfast
Steve got the Rooster Special, which included two pancakes, bacon, two eggs, and grits. Other options included spicy sausage, potatoes, banana bread, or toast. I think he made the right choice with the grits!
Lunch starts at noon and is served until closing time at 2:30pm. Many of their offerings are local or farm-to-table. Since my family and I are from Tennessee originally, we thought it was funny to see a Tennessee Cheese Burger on the menu. As it turns out, the owners bought a farm in Tennessee a few years ago, where they grow herbs, apples, and even raise beef for Blue Heaven!
My dad is a huge fan of yellowtail snapper. He got it every time he saw it on the menu in Key West, including here at Blue Heaven. The Yellow Submarine sandwich comes with vinegar slaw, mango tartar sauce, yellow peppers, and baron pickles on a baguette!
Keep eating: The Best Food in the World
Yellowtail Snapper Salad
Following suit, I got the Yellowtail Snapper Salad, which came with miso eggplant (yum), chevre cheese, orange cider vinaigrette, and buttered bread. I would definitely recommend it to you, and I’d get it again myself!
Steve got the healthiest option of all, as usual! He chose the Loaded Bowl, which included rice, black beans, romaine, cole slaw, salsa, sour cream, cheddar cheese, and cornbread. You can also add a protein to the bowl if you like, but Steve decided to go vegetarian!
Going solo? How to Enjoy Going Out to Eat Solo
Their Famous Key Lime Pie
Word to the wise… Get there early for the pie! By the time we got around to ordering dessert at 2:00pm, they had just run out of the famous, Mile-high Key Lime Pie! Luckily, I got a slice when we were there in January, but I was bummed my parents didn’t get to try it. Next time!
How do they get the torch on that meringue so even? I asked! They torch it first, then they bake it to make it uniform all the way around!
Save the best for last: The World’s Best Desserts
Want more? Check out all my Florida and Key West blog posts on my United States Page!
Love this post? Pin it for later!